Doctored News Photo Covers Up Government Involvement

The first day of the New Year witnessed the shocking tragedy of the death of a 16-year-old kid at the hands of a traffic patrol vehicle in Sichuan. What made everything worse was the media response afterwards by which newspaper photos were deliberately doctored using PhotoShop to remove the label “路政巡查” [Road Administration Patrol] on the vehicle, in a possible effort to mask any official/governmental links to the accident. This outraged the locals as well as the online community, where many expressed anger and contempt for such shameless cover-up to mislead the public.

From Tianya:

On the afternoon of January 1st at 2:20 pm, 2010; directly facing the Huidong South Lake Gymnasium in Zigong County in Sichuan Province, a Road Administration Patrol vehicle struck and killed a 16-year-old young man — Cheng Zhuo. Witnesses at the scene claimed that the driver was driving under the influence of alcohol, although Zigong Police, at the moment, has not revealed the results of their investigation, and the issue of whether it was drunk driving awaits further investigation. However, the local media at Zigong chose to PhotoShop the photograph [of the accident] and publish it in the local paper, leading to shocking reactions from the public…

Here are the original photos from the scene of the accident. Clearly the words “路政巡查” are printed on the front of the patrol vehicle only to mysteriously disappear in the news photo.

Unidentified man in camouflage fatigues with a policeman shortly after the accident.

“Who is this?”

“This police officer should know what happened at the time.”

Picture as it appeared on the newspaper’s website.

Comments on Tianya :

kevin3311:

Absurd, so shameless it is incomprehensible, all tmd crazy.

今天的天气很不错:

Shameless media, shameless reporter/prostitute.

Note: The ji (记) in “reporter” sounds the same as the ji (妓) in “prostitute”. The commenter intentionally used a pun.

wushuk2009:

Zigong’s “Daily Evening News” must take responsibility. Their workers can refuse to do such a thing, and doing what they are doing now can be suspected of the crime of forgery. Did the person who PS this consider this? By principle, if the Evening News workers all refused to make this kind of PS, then the paper’s boss can not manipulate things. Whoever wants to PS, and then the boss can tell the other side to do it themselves. One side is breaking the law, the other side is “opposing the leaders”, do you chose to break the law or to oppose the leaders? Do you choose the rule of law or the rule of man? Don’t say that the Evening News have no responsibility.

正宗风尘仆仆:

Hope there are no special privilege cars in heaven.

Patrol cars like the one involved in this accident typically have “special privileges” allowing them to disobey normal traffic rules.

筱漫漫:

Why erase the words “路政巡查”[Road Administration Patrol]? Where is the truth in the news? The related agencies must thoroughly investigate this event.

zhaofan17:

Ding, shameless scum, they must have received money to keep their mouth shut.

爱过你一文不值:

The news media were always the eunuchs of the Party.

落进侠士:

A routine traffic accident, dragged into a storm of controversy from a photoshopped picture.

美年达美味:

Law enforcement’s lack of justice and transparency makes me mad!

学_习_长_大:

A child’s departures makes one grief, ZF‘s reaction makes one disheartened, the reports in the papers makes one angry!

The Victim: Cheng Zhuo

The student killed in the accident was named Cheng Zhuo. Here are some photos and achievements that Chinese netizens posted online following this incident:

Cheng Zhuo was an honor student with many academic awards.

Comments on QQ:

::L.磊::

angry Immediately execute the driver of the car!!!

中安传媒/pj:

What a shame, a good student!

沈浪:

angrycry A car accident is already a heartbreaking tragedy, only to face alteration of the news! Where is the truth? Where is justice? Severely punish the perpetrators! Punish those tarnishing the image of the government! Save your own conscience, don’t you have families of your own?

/、俹思:

Today’s society, can be so black.

桑野:

In the eyes of those agencies in power, what worth do the lives of others have?

I predict they spent some stinkin’ money to marginalize/trivialize this whole event, making it unimportant.

The Official Government Response and Statement

From Sichuan News Online:

January 6th, Zigong (Liu Lin, Zhou Hanyu). January 1st, 2010, a traffic accident resulting in one death and one wounded at the Luisheng public bus stop on 33rd road in Zigong, has been brought into the attention of the Zigong Municipal Party Committee and Municipal Government. Committee leaders commented: “We must swiftly reach a conclusion, and severely deal with the problem, to give the public a proper answer.” The night of the 5th at 10:00 pm, Zigong government news bureau at Huidong Hotel held a news conference, informing the investigation results of the traffic accident.

Zigong Traffic Police, Huidong New District Traffic Police force announced the results of their investigation: The day they received the emergency call, the police on duty immediately reached the scene, to investigate and manage [the scene]. After investigation, [it was determined that] at around 2 pm, Sichuan Longhao Road Investment Company driver Liu Ning was driving a company vehicle, with the license plate C-45365, traveling along Huichuan Road toward the highway; upon reaching “Xiang Xie Li She” Hotel on Jingguan Boulevard and turning left into a non-vehicle road, he hit a man surnamed Wang and Cheng Zhuo waiting by the bus stop, then hitting a medium size truck, with the license plate C-10470, parked on the road, causing Cheng Zhuo to die at the scene, Wang injured, and two vehicles receiving different degrees of damage.

Official report of the accident

In addressing the citizen’s concerns of “whether the driver was driving under the influence of alcohol,” Huidong New District Traffic Police, Officer Cheng Zhong explained: The day of the incident, police immediately led the driver causing the accident Liu Ling to the hospital to take blood samples, and sent the samples to Sichuan Huaxi Medical Center for analysis. On January 4th, the analysis report showed that Liu Ling’s blood did not contain alcohol. Zigong Municipal Party Committee, Municipal Inspection Department, Chief Huang Yonghuai expressed: Our city’s inspection agencies highly value the importance of the incident on the first of January, sending someone specifically to investigate the issue of the vehicle causing the accident, which was printed with “路政巡查” [Road Administration Patrol] and “installed with law enforcement sirens”. After the problem is fully investigated, we will handle it according to the related laws and rules.

The driver suspected of causing the accident Liu Ling at the moment has already been detained. Under the care of related agencies the wounded have already received proper treatment. According to the specified procedures in handling this incident, Huidong New District Traffic Police have already on the 5th notified the concerned party with the accident report, autopsy report, and alcohol report. At the moment, this incident is still under investigation in accordance with the law.

Report indicate no alcohol was found in the driver's blood

Classmates Mourn The Student’s Death

Here are some pictures of Cheng Zhuo’s classmates mourning his death by lighting Kongming Lanterns by the bridge, as a way of lighting the path guiding him to heaven. Some classmates wrote their parting eulogy for their good friend.

Share This Article

49 Comments

  • Some HTML can be used to format your comment.
  • Add a picture to your comments with Gravatar.
  • Our Comment Policy.
  1. The news system is managed by party/gov.

  2. Sofawolf?? Ich bin dem technowoooolf!

  3. Here’s to hoping his classmates will grow up doubting authority.

  4. HI I AM BAAAAAAAAAAAAACKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK!!!!!!!!
    well, we are not sure why they modified the picture or if there is any official involved in the case. Corruption is in every country but in china they dont bother making it discret. Poor boy, looks smart.

  5. What a predictable response from the biased Western media!

    …wait. Someone should notify anti-CNN about this.

  6. OH, shock and horror!!?! Gasp!
    When I lived in Sichuan, a building fell down one morning at 7am. Yes…an inhabited building. By 9 there was a wall around the site and machines (!) arrived to clean up. My friend was a news TV reporter for teh local station…
    “Are you going to get the story?”
    “…story?…What story?”

  7. Young and promising student with bright future. My condolence for him and his family

  8. Its China…..a place that only all the government official is above tha law…..only the peasant are subject to the law.

  9. some updates:

    1) The original article with forged the photo was publish on Jan 4th on Zigong Evening News and the newspaper’s PDF version is here:

    http://www.zgtoday.com/pdf/20100107/A03.pdf

    2) Western Chinese City Daily (a much larger newspaper with more than one million daily circulation) also published on Jan 3rd an article that covers the same incident and mentioned the car’s sign and siren.

    http://www.wccdaily.com.cn/epaper/hxdsb/html/2010-01/03/content_141012.htm

    3) Why the vehicle has “patrol” sign and siren?

    http://www.zgtoday.com/dianzi/jrwb/html/2010-01/06/content_60881.htm

    The car belongs to Longhao Highway Co. LTD, a company that makes a variety of highway facilities such as speed cameras, traffic signs etc. The vehicle got the painting and siren legally but it doesn’t belongs to a government department and the driver is the company’s employee.

    4) so what is Road Administration Patrol anyway? I have no clear answer but my best guess is it’s possibly related to works on highway construction and maintenance.

    5) why the hell the newspaper forged the picture? they gave an ‘explanation and apologize’ on the same forum where the scandal was first publicized(but not on the newspaper itself):

    bbs.zg163.net/bbs/viewthread.php?tid=1088581&page=1

    3日晚,编辑部值班编辑在处理该稿件图片时,鉴于肇事车挂有警示灯,车身印有“自贡路政”、“路政巡查”等字样,但其所属单位不是执法部门、肇事司机不是执法人员,在原因不明确的情况下,出于谨慎,擅自处理掉了图片中“路政巡查”字样

    basically the editor on duty photoshopped the sign on the vehicle because he/she “hasn’t been sure for the reason why a sign and a siren appeared on a vehicle that doesn’t belong to a law enforcement department”. WTF!

    Guess what will happen to Zigong Evening News’ circulation!

    • I’m sure that an underling at the newspaper will get fired and made a scapegoat, and the bosses who tried to cover it up will keep their jobs.

  10. 2:20 pm NOT am and already slamdanced in a state owned vehicle… poor form

  11. The Chininks are good at PS …

  12. Chinese people pretend to be outraged by this shit but then they’ll read a copy of The Economist in which Wen Jiabao is called “stale” or something like that and they’ll scream HOW DARE THE BIASED FOREIGN MEDIA OFFEND CHINA WITH THEIR DISGUSTING LIES ABOUT BELOVED GRANDPA WEN!

    EVERY Chinese newspaper article is just as loaded with bullshit as the front page of that newspaper but they refuse to see it. Their whole worldview is built around a framework of such bullshit that only the most obvious lies anger them.

    • He might be a jerk… but when he’s right, he’s f-n right!

    • Whenever you read this type of shit you get the same predictable shit responses. The fact is that both Chinese media and the foreign media suck when it comes to reporting about China. Both reports only from a single point of view and rarely give the other side a chance.

      It’s retarded to justify the crappiness of the Chinese media by bringing up how one sided foreign media is. It’s just as stupid trying to justify how crappy foreign media is by mocking the Chinese media. But I guess it’s always entertaining to watch the two sides have flame wars.

  13. chine needs democracy.in a one-party system country,dont you think that disgusting thing happened impossible?no useful to blame the editors,the journalists,the police.in one sentence,chine needs a wise politician to challenge the current situation.expect a chinese-type democracy!

  14. Hi. I’m a DICK-tator.:D

  15. Well, on the eve of october 1 2009 I witness a little accident of a military minibus (20-30 people) with a car in Haidian. The first they did was to cover both plates with newspapers… Harmony at any price: if it is not there, it did not exist

  16. There is no Ryugyong Hotel.

    Oceania is at war with Eastasia, always has been.

  17. Someone send this to papa bear O’Reilly. I want to hear him tear into the Chinese government.

  18. The sad part of this whole mess is the lose of life of a young 16 year old man and the fact that his family and friends will no longer have him around because of the driver’s stupidity.

  19. idiots, they should have photo shopped the red and blue sirens out too.

  20. Same old cover up, sweep it under the carpet, hope nobody noticed. Feel sorry for the victim, hope the parents gets the real truth and some answers. At least one thing is working the human flesh search engine.

  21. the publicity will increase the compensation a little bit for the parents of victim – that’s it. This is fucking china, where laws apply only to the powerless, what do you expect?

  22. So I took the day off. China decided to PR for itself.

  23. I have to credit China with being number one in PR.

  24. So, the system is corrupt, so, the gov officials is corrupt, so, the police is corrupt, so.. what are you going to do about it other than talk and talk? Absolutely NOTHING…

    • Talk and complain is what Chinese people like to do. And this story (like most crimes) will be forgotten in a few weeks. Not much changes here.

    • Absolutely nothing…I have to disagree.

      Talking is something. In the old days, only a few people would have known about a cover-up; today, millions know within a few hours.

      The mere fact that this story is on Chinasmack means the people have done something huge. The government rightly loathes bad press; isn’t it likely that at some point in the future, a government official will have the option of influencing someone one way or the other, and will think of this incident, and decide NOT to Photoshop something?

      And how about the poor slob who actually did the PS-ing; his/her fate will spread from person to person, and the next poor slob faced with the decision to PS or not might try to say no.

      Talk has a HUGE effect. If talk didn’t have an effect, Hu wouldn’t devote billions of RMB to “channeling public opinion.”

  25. Dongguan is full of knife-wielding thieves from the northwest and the police are afraid to do anything about it.

    The thieves are so unrestrained that they freely loiter in front of busy stores stealing and robbing at will. It may seem like I’m exaggerating but I’m not. You can visit Carrefour in Dongcheng district anytime, especially on the weekends, and you will see gangs from 5 to more then 10 in a group running around trying to put their hands into peoples shopping bags then yelling threats when they are caught.

    One of these thieves pulled a knife on me (it was just a matter of time)and tried to rob me. I yelled for help to two policemen who were standing near by. The thief then flashed his knife to the police and, believe it or not, the police just turned their heads and ignored me.

    The police were afraid of the thief and they would not help me! F*cking Cowards!

    I then started shouting to people around me and fortunately the thief lost interest and walked away. I went to the police department in Dongcheng and the police said they can do nothing to stop the knife-wielding thieves.

    How can a police department refuse to protect it citizens?

  26. Stories like these (where the rich and powerful gets away with unlawful acts and the migrant and poorer citizens get screwed) occur frequently in China. Remember the poor waitress Deng Yujiano who stabbed a government official in Hubei. Or the rape case involving a high school student in Huzhou City. And none of the corrupt building officials responsible for the shoddy construction in Sichuan that collasped after the massive earthquake have been charged. All of these cases were either ruled in favor of the defendant (because of their ties to the CCP) or thei sentences greatly reduced.

    However, what my main comment here today is how amateurish the various cover-ups seem (which provides fuel for the media and the Western world). Does anybody think that a simple Photoshop job will make people think it is not a government vehicle? How many civilian cars are there in China that have flashing lights on the roof of the car? The evidence against this photo is too simple for people to obtain and makes the government cover-up look silly and amateurish. Same with the China’s Olympic gymnasts. They claim that the gymnasts are of appropriate age, yet time and time again, internal records from national and provincial tournament show the girls at a much younger age. The explanation was that these were just simple clerical errors on the part of the tournament registration officials. If it happened once and people call you out, you can defended it as a clerical error. But to happen multiple multiple times (in addition with the gymnast’s parents providing no comment) provides suspicion. You would think that they would be more diligent and careful every time after the first time to avoid further scrutiny.

    My point being, China’s cover-ups (if they are truly cover-ups) are so amateurish that it makes their point ever harder to believe.

  27. There’s so many weird cars in China, people wouldn’t think twice about it

  28. Meanwhile this morning on CCTV9, for at least the 2nd or 3rd time, the all-important story of Hainan trying to become an international tourist hotspot was one of the top stories…
    The “news” is really hard to swallow here sometimes.

  29. i dont remember ever saying that the reason i post is for shitheads like you to judge. What would be the use of chinasmack if all post were to be good ones. Wake up shithead. You think offending me will stop me from posting again? try a new method.

  30. Unbelievable! I also lived in Haikou for a few years!!!
    Anything you’ve heard about Hainan is probably true!

  31. we should make a poll to see who is the most stupid / hated / weird poster in Chinasmack. I propose the following candidates: LAOWAIXIAN, PUSAN PLAYA, FUCKDALUREN.

  32. hello jean, i would like to know if possible why do you think i am the most stupid one ? thank you for your precious time madame. have a good day

  33. BECAUSE, im a GUY. Lol.

  34. You really can’t put LAOWAIXIAN in the same category as PUSAN PLAYA and fuckdaluren. The second two actually make good points and often do it in a humorous (and offensive) manner. For crying out, even if you hate what those two say, you have to laugh at the way they say it. LAOWAIXIAN, on the other hand, just makes a very average point with a very toolish introduction.

  35. “…hello jean, i would like to know if possible why do you think i am the most stupid one ? thank you for your precious time madame. have a good day…”

    HAHAHA.. off to the burns unit again claw hand.

Personals @ chinaSMACK - Meet people, make friends, find lovers? Don't be so serious!»