Shenzhen Chengguan Abandon One Of Their Own To Face Mob

An embarrassed-looking chengguan appears to be under the control of a female peddler during an altercation

From Mop:

When an left behind chengguan meets the iron fist of a street vendor, the result is tragedy

This is a once in a hundred years set of pictures.

A city management officials [chengguan] unexpectedly being the weaker party/victim.

His body wracked with pain, his left arm attached to an intravenous drip, a male street vendor’s iron fist pounded the glass windshield of an Izuzu law enforcement truck [note that the author may have intentionally made a pun in the Chinese here changing the word for "implement the law" (or "law enforcement") into "implement punishment"] into a shattered cone. (Find a picture and dear audience you will notice that regardless of whether it is the police or the city management officials, the vehicles all seem to be Japanese cars. However, it’s now proven that in the face of angry Chinese street peddlers, these vehicles are so weak that they can not withstand just one punch —- Is it because the [quality of the] car is garbage or because the street peddler is a martial arts master? No way to tell.)

The left-behind city management official, like a chick that has left a mother hen’s protection, trembling, allowed the female street vendor to seize hold of his sacred uniform that may or may not have been imprinted with the Chinese national seal. One button, then two buttons, popped off as the shirt was wrinkled, exposing his bulging white belly and chest….as two public security personnel, one on his left, one on his right, securely held the city management official by his arms and shoulders —- This kind of treatment was something that has always been enjoyed by street vendors, but today the universe has unexpectedly been turned upside down, where black has become white, and white has become black.

Of the roadside onlookers, some were numb/indifferent, some applauded, some cheered, some applauded and cheered, and there was one onlooker who was at the police station [because] as was reported in the news, one onlooker who supported of the street peddler was subpoenaed by the police [as an eyewitness] as the police were not present, and the other city management officials had long ago fled to who knows where. The public security personnel, standing with the people, detained the left-behind city management official. All at once, he looked so innocent, so helpless, so frightened, so terrified. However, from his sideways glance, a sliver of vicious hate that foretold of him one day returning with his fellow city management officials to exact revenge could be clearly seen!

This altercation between street vendors and the city management officials occurred on Taoyuan Street in the Luohu district in Shenzhen, and it appears that the city management officials were thoroughly defeated.

City management officials have always looted in packs, so it’s unknown why this time they left behind a single lonesome prisoner. Was it because they couldn’t vanquish this martial arts master of a male street peddler and ran off? Or is it because the quickly gathering onlooking masses who do not know the truth caused them to cowardly flee? Either way, all we see is a single face, “humiliated” by a street peddler, filled with helplessness, and jeered by the surrounding crowd.

People often say: A single Chinese person by himself is a dragon, but a group of Chinese people together is a worm. For city management officials, it is precisely the opposite, where a group of city management officials are savage like wolves and tigers, but a single city management official is like a poor pitiful caterpillar.

This truly is a brilliant searing send-up of a parody, something that can be forever enshrined as a major incident in the history of the illegal and illegitimate organization that is the city management [department]. It proves that city management officials truly are the weak, and indeed ought to be mocked for their illegitimacy.

Truly amusing! Truly should be laughed at —- You , you, you… you too [can suffer such a humiliation/defeat]!

But on the contrary, I am not laughing.

In being abandoned by his own teammates, being manhandled by a female street vendor to the point where his uniform is torn to rags, and being ridiculed by the onlooking crowd, I believe the self-esteem of that city management official has suffered a heavy blow. He is probably thinking two things, with one being: Just wait until I come back with reinforcements, and see how I’m going to teach you poor bastards a lesson; The other being: Dammit, I’m never going to work as a lousy city management official ever again, I’d rather go set up a stall/stand [be a street vendor/peddler] and be chased off by city management officials than endure being laughed by the crowds again.

—- That latter thought should be occupying the majority of the space in his mind. After all, when his parents, wife and child have seen their own loved one hanging his head like a captured enemy being spit upon by the masses, think of how intensely they will persuade him not to enter such murky waters again.

Rich people would not go be city management officials. The all-imposing and domineering city management personnel are actually just some poor people, the weak. They simply bully Xiao D’s Ah Q [allusion to Lu Xun's "The True Story of Ah Q", a story where a poor peasant would use complex reasoning to justify a sense of self-superiority in any situation]. The strong draw swords against those who are stronger, whereas the weak raise fists against those who are weaker.

After obtaining the snot [tiny, insignificant] power granted by the city management system, these city management officials who came from the lowest level of society become eager to show that they have become the strong, to have people fear them, strengthening themselves to get the “respect” they could not get as the weak. So when street peddlers scatter and flee when they see them, that feeling [they get], can “refreshing/invigorating” even begin to describe it? When the street vendors who couldn’t flee in time are before them groveling and lighting their cigarettes, that feeling of power, how can they not suddenly experience orgasm and howl with pleasure?

In the past when great [foreign] powers “used Chinese to control/govern the Chinese”, we saw that our compatriots were far more vigorous and vicious to their own than towards foreigners. Likewise the city management system of “the poor controlling/governing the poor” undoubtedly greatly arouses the violent desires of those who just yesterday were lowly nobodies but today are the high and mighty big dogs and wolves.

Having seen so many street vendors/peddlers shaking before the tyranny of city urban management officials, and then seeing a city management official reduced to ashes under the strong attacks of a street peddler, I really find myself unable to laugh.

Poor people, why are you making things more difficult for other poor people?

Comments from Mop:

美女爱自拍:

So what happened in the end?smiling pink cloud

悟能不是ZHU:

Looks like both diplomacy and violence is what’s most important.

西京浪人:

How could this have happened?

亲亲BoA:

At the time I was standing right next to the photographer [who took these pictures]. I don’t know if everybody has noticed that the peddler is covered from head to toe in blood. Do you know the reason why he was attempting to smash the car window? It’s because the weapon the chengguan used to stab him with was lying behind the windshield, Li Yong wanted to grab the knife that stabbed him!!!!! Editor/writer, why didn’t you reveal the truth behind all of this? Who or what are you safeguarding? Everything I’m saying I saw with my own two eyes. Editor/writer please don’t delete my post, the common people have the right to know the truth!!

Posting the original images:

Peddlar Li Yong strikes a law enforcement vehicle in front of onlookers and emergency service personnel

An embarrassed-looking chengguan appears to be under the control of a female peddler during an altercation; peddler Li Yong sits in front of a smashed law enforrcement vehicle with bloodied wounds

An embarrassed-looking chengguan appears to be under the control of a female peddler during an altercation

An embarrassed-looking chengguan appears to be under the control of a female peddler during an altercation
不准登录:

City management personnel enforcing the law by using knives to stab people?!

深水探底:

The image of a prosperous China is actually a superficial one. There are few professional/rich people, but many poor people. Although the chengguan are very violent, as they encounter more and more poor people, the use of violence will surely fail.

周吖丫:

Evil.

卖身_葬楼主:

Beat them, beat these bastards to death.

danielj521:

[I] commend this!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Cartoon of "Respect my authroitah!"

[Above: "Accept my corrective influence! Ha hahaha!"]

笨猪一只!:

Cities need to take care of their image, peddlers need to make a living.

在无聊中永生:

Haha, this guy is niu.

A humorous photoshop of a sheepish chengguan being confronted by the United States President

[Above: President Obama: "Hey you, do you work for Osama Bin Laden? Chengguan: "NO!!!" President Obama: “Don‘t you give me that shit! You're even more niubi than Bin Laden himself!]

匿名人士79111:

Dammit, if you’re going try making it sound like a news article, at least try being a bit more professional. This was a Luohu district of Shenzhen peddler who was beaten by a group of urban management officials, and suffered grievous injuries. But in your hands, it became a fucking case of the peddler beating up the chengguan.

通关蜜语:

Haha, serves him right, those city management officials suffering misfortune is exactly what I want to see….. I’m so happy~~

漂在路上:

No matter what is said, it isn’t right to break [other people's] things.

鱼疯仔:

Everybody is just trying to make a living, can’t we all just get along? You have stress [pressures and responsibilities], I have stress, do we really have to be at each others throats?

From JF Daily:

Once again chengguan seen violently enforcing the law, this time in Shenzhen

On the 21st, a street vendor named Li Yong suffered injuries from blows administered by chengguan officials in an conflict that took place in Shenzhen. [Li Yong's] wife grabbed hold of the shirt of one of the members of the opposing side and demanded harsh punishment for this chengguan who had assaulted [her husband]. The situation remained deadlocked for a good part of an hour, and this incident once again calls into question the methods chengguan use to handle their duties.

Yesterday, this Morning Post reporter contacted the still convalescing principal character of the incident Li Yong, but Li would only reply that he has already signed a settlement agreement with the Sungang Street Branch of the Luohu District Law Enforcement Agency in which he has accepted 7000RMB as compensation.

Unwilling to Clear Out, Beaten by Chengguan

34-year-old Li Yong from Henan province has been in Shenzhen already for four years. He and his wife have sold fruit near Taoyuan Street in Luohu district as a way to make a living. On the afternoon of the 21st, law enforcement officials from the Sungang Street branch of Luohu district began a inspection to clear out illegal street vendors. When law enforcement officials discovered Li Yong had set up his stall on a pedestrian throughway, they requested that he “pack up his stall/stand and fruit.” Li Yong resolutely opposed [this request].

Li Yong explained that just when both sides were deadlocked, a law enforcement cadre named Luo Yang instructed his subordinates, “Beat him, take everything away”, at which point Li Yong suffered injuries to his head from baton strikes, his entire body was dripping with blood. Then, an enraged Li Yong demanded to see the head of the law enforcement office, and used his fist to attack the vehicle glass, shattering the windshield.

An onlooker at the scene dialed 110 [emergency services] and the police and ambulance soon arrived, at which point the subordinate who committed the assault was apprehended. However, Li Yong continued to sit in front of the enforcement vehicle and was not willing to go to the hospital; as well, his wife stubbornly continued to hold onto the shirt of the chengguan subordinate who had committed the assault, attracting many onlookers to the scene.

Signing the Settlement Contract Was a Way to “Make Ends Meet”

Yesterday, this Morning Post reporter contacted Mr Li in a telephone call, Li indicated that he was still convalescing at home and had already signed a “settlement agreement”.

Li Yong said that on the day he was beaten and injured by the law enforcement personnel, the law enforcement agency had suggested a “financial compensation settlement”, but he did not agree. Afterward, both parties had their statements taken and investigated at the police station, and the chengguan subordinate suspected of assault was then released.

On the afternoon of the 22nd, a representative of the Sungang Street Law Enforcement Agency of Luohu district sought out Li Yong to make a “settlement”. After a moment of consideration, Li Yong agreed to sign the settlement. Mr Li goes on to say that the settlement states that the chengguan agency accepts the responsibility of all his previously incurred medical expenses but not his later medical expenses to come, and henceforth both sides agree to no longer pursue liability. After signing the settlement contract, Mr Li received 7000RMB in compensation.

Li Yong states that his heart is not willing to accept the 7000RMB of compensation but after considering that in the future he still has to continue to sell fruit to make a living, he decided to finally sign. Mr Li says during the entire ordeal the law enforcement officials have not once apologized to him.

Captain Feng Zhong of the Sungang Street Law Enforcement Agency stated in an interview with this reporter that images of law enforcement personnel beating and injuring Li Yong were not found amongst video of the incident, and that the injuries sustained by Mr Li in the confrontation were likely accidental.

Stab. Personals @ chinaSMACK.

  • xmcx

    poor guy no sofa for him

  • Confucius says

    Wow, he got stabbed and he still have enough energy to beat him to a pulp?

    Brother admire.

  • Nanjing

    What’s up with the IV? Why does everybody who’s hurt always receive an IV in China?

    • Ethan JRT

      I don’t know, but friends who say it works wonders when you’re ill. Maybe it’s morphine :-p

    • donscarletti

      Yeah, it’s quite standard, you often see rooms full of chairs with IV bags racks being used at near capacity in hospitals, especially in summer. They’re used for fever and many other things and they do have a moderately positive effect, particularly since most people not properly hydrated for a lot of the day.

      I’ve been offered them before, but first time I had one as a kid, I somehow ripped it out and pretty much shredded the vein in my forearm before regaining consciousness after a general anesthetic. I woke up with my forearm stitched up, second IV not far below my elbow, a splint and like nine layers of bandages so I couldn’t do it again. They kind of make me think of that.

    • Jon

      The reason practically every health complaint is first treated with an IV is because the public is misinformed of its usefulness and hospitals see this as an opportunity to make some easy cash. Generally the IV is a saline solution with antibiotics, and is useless in treating the common cold, influenza, and a wide array of other common health problems. If a person is able to drink water and swallow a pill, there’s little legitimate reason to administer an intravenous drip, and zero reason to use it in treating any virus-caused illness.

      Furthermore, the widespread overuse of antibiotics is dangerous to public health, as such practice can result in hardened strains of dangerous bacteria that become increasingly resistant to antibiotic treatment. Unless you have a serious infection and treat it with a prolonged and full regimen of antibiotics, you are better off letting your body’s immune system fight the infection naturally.

      In some cases, antibiotic IVs can be used as a preventative measure against infection. Actually, I think in the case of Mr. Iron Fist Peddler above, its use is somewhat justified, since he appears to be bleeding and may possibly have received a puncture wound. However, a dose of penicillin and a cup of water would have worked just as well for a fraction of the price.

      Unless it is inadvisable to consume medicine and liquids orally, or a person is otherwise unable to do so, generally there isn’t a whole lot of need for unspecialized IVs. (IVs with doses of patient-specific medicine may be another thing, especially in treating less common diseases and after surgeries).

      The way they are administered in China is pretty much an officially-sanctioned scam.

    • 平凡人

      It’s money and a fast way of containing the problem, makes people think it works. Unfortunately it prevents the body of developing anti-bodies to counter the virus but makes the virus stronger as time goes by. It makes a person weak against virus in the future.

      • Jon

        Actually, antibiotics are used to treat bacterial illness only, and are completely ineffective against viruses.

      • Chris

        Also doesn’t really stop the body from making antibodies, unless the IV actually contains antibodies against said bacteria/virus/toxin.

    • CM

      I used to get under the weather a lot when I was a kid in China, now I have a collapsed vein on my left hand from IV

    • Cardaver

      Placebo treatment, placebo effect

  • GreenTea

    damn mall cops.

  • Jones

    I like how he took a special time out to criticize the Japanese through their vehicles.

  • Alikese

    To OP on Mop: You’re not Charles Dickens, enough with your self-masturbatory prose. Tell your stupid story about Chengguan so we can get our schadenfreude and move on.

    • Jones

      Jesus thank you

    • http://candosino.wordpress.com terroir

      I get the sense that “schadenfreude with Chinese characteristics” requires one person to marginally take the lead so that everyone else can fall in step closely behind and together act as a cohesive unit, like a bunch of Chinese un-MILFs who are holding fans and roughly moving in unison and furthermore may also be coincidentally dancing.

  • Master Huang

    Is that a red underwear? bloody english

    • http://baihaifeng.blogspot.com Dr. Jones Jr.

      So the chengguan was born in the ‘year of the rabbit’? I guess that probably makes him 36 years old, as he doesn’t look 48 or 24.

  • Peye

    Perhaps it would be possible to set up marketplaces where the street vendors can open their stalls. It seems to be a difficult situation when shop owners have to pay rent for their space and street vendors are using public spaces free of charge. Of course beating on people is not the way to correct the problem. But I think in a system where poverty and great want are still present, yet where a new way of making a living and of doing business is emerging, people may have to expect these confrontations for a while longer. Looks like some negotiations need to take place between vendors and the city government to establish rules that can be accepted by both parties. But in any case there are limits to what can be tolerated in order to be able to maintain a livable and healthy environment for all citizens.

    • http://mysticalmagicpages.blogspot.com/ Tommy

      Selling fruit from fruit stalls isn’t “a new way to make a living.”

      • anon

        Haha, yeah, I think Peye means something alone the lines of poor people going to break the official rules as long as there is enough demand for them to make a living, and as a result, you’ll get confrontations between them and the authorities.

    • anon

      Good comment. For the most part, I think there are rules (tacit and explicit) that both parties (in general, the city authorities and the street peddlers) already accept. While these violent confrontations regularly make the news, the vast majority of the time, the chengguan and street peddlers coexist quite uneventfully. The street peddlers more or less all understand the reasoning behind the regulations the chengguan are tasked with enforcing. The chengguan more or less are also sympathetic with people trying to make a living in whatever way they can. The understanding that is observed most of the time is that the chengguan rarely do more than they absolutely have to (they mostly make symbolic sweeps or ad hoc sweeps as mandated by higher-ups) to keep their jobs and the street peddlers comply. When the chengguan come, the peddlers should leave and come back when they’re gone to continue doing business. Give the chengguan face in the execution of their duties and the chengguan usually let you do your thing the rest of the time.

      But when you have so many people involved, you always get a few people messing things up for this or that reason. You might have some overzealous chengguan who is out to abuse his power, or you might have an obstinate street peddler who decides he isn’t going to play by the unspoken rules that day. Confrontations happen, things escalate, people get hurt.

      These confrontations will definitely continue happening, because they represent an inevitable clash between different interests sharing territory. You have city officials who want to fashion the public space in one way, while you have the poor who see such public spaces as places where they can make money. You have poor people who like the convenience and prices of street peddlers, while you also have the wealthier people who begin finding them unsightly, unsanitary, and undesirable.

      Ultimately, as the surrounding area becomes more wealthy, they’ll find ways to push these street peddlers out who will then more or less naturally flock to areas where other poor people are who appreciate their services. Something to look at are the night markets of Taiwan as well as the “streets” of Hong Kong and how they’ve evolved over time but it’d be a mistake to think those places got where they are now (which is much better than 20-30 years ago) overnight. Such places also faced a lot of the same “city officials” vs “street peddler” problems we see here. It’s just the nature of the game.

      • Chris

        Kinda tough for the law enforcement too. I don’t approve of their methods, but you have to be able to enforce some sort of law.

        Hard to find the right balance.

      • Li Ruike

        So, what you’re saying (so confidently) is that Taiwan, Hong Kong, and mainland China all have the same underlying economic playing fields. It’s just that Taiwan and Hong Kong have had more 20 to 30 more years to perfect their game. Right? It’s just the balance between the needs of the rich and poor, right? Nothing else matters, right? Taiwan and Hong Kong used to have chengguan who were also occasionally violent, right? But time, the great healer, has allowed things to naturally mature. (Sarcasm.)

        Check out how Hong Kong and Taiwan rank compared to China in the Ease of Doing Business Index:
        http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ease_of_Doing_Business_Index
        China ranks at #75 in 2011, and it’s safe to say that it used to be worse. But can we say that “time” has improved China, or has recognizing that Hong Kong and Taiwan (not to mention the failed economic policies of the former Soviet Union) are economically smarter and relaxing the retarded (literally) communist economic policies made the difference?

        Time fixes nothing. Only wise and intelligent decisions make things better. That’s why China should be fully united with Taiwan and Hong Kong, but only if one of them becomes the new center of government. This country would then truly thrive.

        • anon

          I didn’t say time and time alone fixes anything, though I do imagine most people understand such a proposition as being similar to “you’ll get over her eventually”.

          I do think much of the clashes between street vendors and the chengguan are related to the interests of different segments of society often delineated along differences of wealth. I don’t think “nothing else matters”.

          Taiwan and Hong Kong STILL have city officials tasked with upholding city ordinances and regulations. My point is that they’ve dealt with the same problems before, and it is instructive to look at all the factors that have contributed to how they have evolved over time to what the situation is like in such places now. Certain decisions by those involved will certainly affect the timetable of “change”, but time is still an unavoidable requisite. For example, it takes time for regulations to be enacted and enforced. It takes time for those being regulated to modify their normative behaviors. This was true in Hong Kong, Taiwan, and every where else. It remains true for China.

          Wise and intelligent decisions certain can make things better, but life and society is not so simple because your wise and intelligent decisions can be rendered moot and largely irrelevant by the actions of another. Hence, it is the interaction of all actors that matters. I’m saying that the interaction of street vendors and chengguan here isn’t unique and we’ve seen this before and we’ll see it again. Clashes occur when you have people with drastically different interests borne out of drastically different life circumstances and necessities. City officials enacting ordinances and regulations against street peddlers represents certain interests while street peddlers violating these ordinances and regulations represents other interests. You can’t exactly mandate these differences away. The Communists tried.

          What you can do, as a government, is do your best to foster a convergence of interests if your goal is to reduce the clashes that arise from differences of interests. But you also need to accept that when so many players and interests are involved, that things won’t always work out the way and in the time you want them to. Just ask Chiang Kai-shek. You think his timetable for China’s economic development into the modern world was 1970s-80s Taiwan?

          I understand you think China needs to unite with Taiwan and adopt the governance of either Taiwan or Hong Kong but I don’t really understand what your objection is with my comment. Ultimately, my comment is that this phenomenon is similar to what we’ve seen elsewhere. It boils down to a clash of social interests and many of the same factors that influenced changes in such a situation in other places will also apply here. Those include the relative wealth of the actors involved, the municipal policies instituted, the enforcement of such policies, and the passage of time required for adoption and adaptation to such changes in the situation. I’m not sure how you can rationally disagree or find fault with that.

          If you think the answer lies in simple governance alone, then I’d have to excuse myself from the conversation you’re having with yourself.

  • 平凡人

    Are they law enforcement officers or are they from the triad?

  • King Tubby

    Doing your job for you, Kedafu.

    Beat on the Brat with a Bat – The Ramones

    I will be impressed when we get a good old fashioned neck lacing. Then it will be Burn Rubber – The Gap Band.

    • http://www.qq.com/1325279774 Kedafu

      had no internet for x4 days at the house….
      signed up with a new internet company, called, “Great Wall Broadband Network” still getting 50c!

      Old school song….. Comrade King Tubby

      Going with new school

      March of the Pigs
      -Nine Inch Nails

      6.4 is right around the corner…..

      wumaodang

  • Xia
    • Nathan

      Please, never refer us to the Daily Heil again. I dont care how good the story is.

      • KfU

        Actually Nathan, the online version is not bad –

        What with the BBC’s massively one-sided domestic coverage, making it effectively Liebour’s “Pravda”, and The Times going behind the pay wall – I’ve been trying out different avenues of online news…

        The Daily Mail is one of the most viewed web-based news portals worldwide, apparently. It’s very different to the paper version of the Daily Mein Kampf we can buy at the newsagents back home…

        It’s the same with the Guardian online – I’d never buy the Bolshevik rag in the UK, but some of the online stuff is okay, as long as you avoid clicking on anything written by Polly Toynbee. I recommend the audio/podcasts section. . .

        Still, my new favourite has to be The Telegraph – maybe a bit pro-Tory for you, but has a lot of balanced stuff on there. . .

        … as far as the article:

        Chenguan inflict violence on the poorest people in society – what’s new?

        … as far as the Chenguan go:

        they’re out-numbered 100000:1, everyone seems to hate them, yet they seem to be able to do what ever they want – perhaps the solution is for the people to grow some balls or stop complaining and just get on with it.

        However, my favourite part of the article has to be the writer’s sly dig at quality of Japanese car makers. . . “whilst Rome burns, etc….”

      • Justin

        But “don’t you ever crave to appear on the front of the Daily Mail, for less than your mother’s bridal veil?”

    • anon

      How exactly is that any more newsworthy than this story?

      That Daily Mail headline is pretty amusing, but also a great example of why a lot of people think it is garbage.

    • http://candosino.wordpress.com terroir

      Samurai swords are indiginous to Japan, which is an ocean and a gigantic life-long grudge away from China; rather, it’s more likely that another laowai can’t tell the difference between China and Japan just like nobody cares about the difference between Ireland and Scotland and that place where some famous dead princess’ son just got married.

      • http://candosino.wordpress.com terroir

        Maybe Chinese “one day bad dad” in fact does have a Japanese samurai sword in his sedan because many were left behind the last time Japan decided to take a extended national picnic/rape holiday in China. It could even be a Hanzo Hattori.

        • http://candosino.wordpress.com terroir

          I suppose I shouldn’t be too hard on a reporter who can’t tell the difference between Chinese and Japanese reporters. After all, “Memoirs of a Geisha” was a bitchin’ movie.

  • ##BlothaLonely##

    I really doubt if this Chinese obsession with Chengguan will ever stop!

  • Jess

    He’s kinda dressed like a college girl in Florida on Spring Break who strips for money.

  • John Wayne

    Chinese chengguan and security need to brushen up on professionalism and officer safety skills.

  • Hylith

    Was it just me, or did you find the way this “reporter”, reported the news to be extremely annoying?

    “Just the facts ma’am” – Joe Friday

    Sounds like this guy is trying to masturbate his ego and sound like Confucius.

    • anon

      The Mop post? I don’t think the author is a reporter, just some random netizen writing about an incident sharing his thoughts and feelings. It’s a bit long but it has some interesting bits. The whole “laughing, not laughing” part was a bit lame and contrived though, in my opinion.

  • http://www.matthewsawtell.com Matthew A. Sawtell

    This is an incident that is probably going to get some attention in halls of power in Beijing – because it appears that the respect/fear for the first level of government enforcement has ended in some parts of P.R. China. Question is, will respect/fear for other government enforcement organizations begin to end as well.

  • Pingback: Browser Cleanup Day « re:education

  • The Other Guy

    Wow, this truly is horrendous.
    Who knew that such heinous acts could be committed in this day and age.
    What would compel someone to act with such violence on something so innocent.
    Seriously, Was that innocent van alright? I hope it didn’t get sent to the junk yard….

  • http://unblockfacebookinchina.info/access-facebook-in-china Rod

    It’s a catch-22. The vendor can’t make enough money and doesn’t have the guanxi to get the right papers to legally sell. Then the chengguan come along who also don’t make enough money to make ends meet unless they take bribes from the street sellers without proper certificates. So then the street vendors don’t have enough money…

  • http://www.makeyourownpheromones.com Michael Hughes

    very long article someone smarize please

  • bunny99

    Saying get rid of the Chengguan and everything will be perfect in Chinese cities is not very realistic. We need Chengguan but not the kind of Chengguan in this story.

    It seems that the Chengguan are victims of the system too. They are just thrown onto the front line with no proper training and told to “just go out and fix all the problems”. They have to do all the dirty work. Really they have one of the most difficult jobs in China. The cities should change their Chengguan recruitment policy and try to recruit more suitable people for this job.

    The Chengguan are not taught how to restrain people without causing them permanent injury. Also, they can be attacked by all of the street vendors and their friends – they have little legal power and no respect, so all they can do is fight. Similarly, if the street vendors refuse to move all the Chengguan know how to do is beat them.

    To fix this problem the Chengguan need help with how to defend themselves and restrain those who violate the city rules without injuring anyone. Also they need to be taught psychology, so they know how to stop a fight and get people to obey the rules by persuasion. Everyone needs to know that the Chengguan have rules to follow (as law enforcement officials similar to police) and have the backing of the police – so that street vendors are less likely to attack them. Finally, they need to work on their image so that everyone will respect them as law enforcement officials and not see them as another street gang.

Personals @ chinaSMACK - Meet people, make friends, find lovers? Don't be so serious!»