“Female Knight” Films & Stops Pickpocket on Shanghai Subway

The young Chinese woman confronts and stops the pickpocket wearing yellow, a woman 7 months pregnant.

From Youku:

Shanghai: Passenger confronts criminal, “Subway Female Knight’s” chivalrous act praised

The woman dubbed “Subway Female Knight” refers to a young woman surnamed Wang who had noticed a woman in purple suspiciously eying people’s bags and purses and decided to use her iPad to film the woman then pickpocketing a mobile phone from another woman boarding the subway train. When Wang confronted the pickpocket, the pickpocket immediately quickly stuff the mobile phone back into the pocket of the victim who had not yet realized what had happened. Wang told the pickpocket to not move and called out to the victim wearing yellow to call the police. Exposed, the pickpocket reacted violently but Wang successfully held her until the police arrived, her head being hit several and her iPad being knocked to the ground in the process. Unfortunately, because the original victim of the pickpocketing had left, the police could not initially file a case.

Wang then posted her experience on her Sina Weibo microblog. By chance, the victim’s cousin saw this and soon the victim, surnamed Xue, contacted the authorities. She even went to Wang’s workplace to personally thank the “female knight” (shown early in the video). Identified by the victim, the pickpocket confessed to her crimes but because she is 7-months pregnant, the police had to release her on bail.

The news anchor ends by saying Miss Wang is deserving of the title of “female knight” for going forth bravely and confronting the crime, but while calling for more people to do such good deeds, he reminds them to be careful of their personal safety.

The victim of pickpocketing thanks the young woman who intervened.In this surveillance footage, the woman in purple pickpockets a mobile phone from the woman in yellow while boarding the subway in Shanghai.

The above video has been viewed over 730k times within 24 hours of being uploaded, making it one of the day’s most popular videos on popular Chinese video sharing website Youku. It is, however, not the first news report of this story. Below is another news report uploaded 3 days ago, before the victim had come forth.

From Youku:

Shanghai: City resident discovers suspicious person, uses iPad to record pickpocketing theft

In the interview, Miss Wang recounts how the pickpocket, while pushing and shoving her on the station platform, defiantly asked her where did she see her stealing, to which Wang replied, “I filmed it with my iPad!”

Young Chinese woman confronts pickpocket on Shanghai subway, dubbed "female knight" by netizens.
Comments from Youku:

ginttd:

And she’s 7-months pregnant… human scum… I bet the child will be no good after it’s born either. Bet it isn’t even her only child too.

醉卧鬼门关:

Engaging in theft even when pregnant, talk about accumulating virtue for one’s child. Go watch A World Without Thieves!

ymlyws:

They’re intentionally using the legal loophole for pregnant women to commit crime.

ZMyGod:

7-months pregnant and still coming out to steal things, how miserable her life must be. (Of course, theft is definitely wrong…)

大家受精了: (responding to above)

These days, a lot of the people stealing things are pregnant women or carrying little children with them, because the relevant laws have a stipulation for such situations, that public security organs [police] cannot imprison that category of people.

22538285: (also responding to ZMyGod)

There are thieving groups like this that, where the ones committing the crimes are specifically women, and a portion of them are even pregnant. The reason is as you saw, because pregnant women can be released on bail.

雨的预言_0001:

Xinjiang people are so shameless! Run them all out of Shanghai!

那―剑的风情:

The baby will also be a criminal.

3179647:

She can indeed be called a “female knight”. In this society, how many people are willing to think of others a bit more? Willing to help each other? This kind of spirit, I support you [her].

chinese1people:

Push her down so she’ll have a miscarriage. That way she can be arrested and taken away [and cannot escape through the pregnancy loophole].

天涯两茫茫:

She’s lucky she’s a woman, because if she were a man, I would’ve gone up and KO’d him.

lionrambo

I watched the surveillance recording twice, and really want to scream! The thief deserves to be condemned, but who should be condemned the most is the subway staff, the one waving the flag! Do you only get paid to wave a flag? There’s a thief, a problem in the subway, within your job scope, and happening just beside you, and you fucking don’t do anything? As if you don’t see it? This society already lacks people who with civic spirit. Such a small subway [station], and you’re obviously staff, if you don’t do something, who will?!!!! Don’t say ensuring subway operation is your main responsibility, don’t say you didn’t know what was happening, don’t say this isn’t within the scope of your job. This is just like a public bus driver discovering a pickpocket and opening the door to let the thief go (to avoid more trouble, saying it will delay today’s efficiency), it’s fundamentally no different!

发克美国:

This showing is better than that Nanjing official!!!!!!

What do you think? About the pickpocketing woman being released? About the girl with the iPad confronting her?

The pickpocket angrily shoves the young woman who exposed her.

  • thetruth

    yay , The sofa is mine. Suck it bitches !!

    • Nanjing

      I don’t know what’s worse, pickpockets who knock ipads on the ground or losers who think “getting the sofa” is something to be proud of.

      • thetruth

        Aww, is the kiddy crying again ??
        Ipad is no big deal in china, anyone can buy it. Even beggars have access to them now.

        • Alan

          Ipad is no big deal in china, anyone can buy it. Even beggars have access to them now.

          Beggars?

          Last I looked in the store here, they are 3,800 rmb a pop.

          Granted some beggars may have them, but I doubt not many.

          Given graduate salaries rarely exceed more than 2,000 a month, if they do buy them it’s packet noodles all month, or on the credit card?!?!

    • Bruce Tutty

      small when you compare it to the world isn’t it

  • Nyancat

    thumbs up to you lady!

  • alex

    Ok let me get this right, the article is simply that a Chinese person helped a stranger…would this have caught any attention at all in another country?

    • anon

      Yes, it would have. Do a search. Here’s one example:

      http://www.nbcdfw.com/news/local/Good-Samaritan-Snaps-Photo-of-Mall-Robber-139930693.html

      It isn’t difficult to understand why this story has gotten attention, and more so than the countless other instances of people helping each other daily that are taken for granted and not given as much attention. The main thing is the social media component, that this girl posted her video and story on Weibo, and that she was already known for her anti-pickpocketing efforts (which isn’t mentioned above but is in the Chinese video and news articles about this). It’s like when members of Reddit organized donations for charity. Her story was made visceral with video, reached people on Chinese Twitter and spread from there.

      The fact that Chinese people, like us, popularly think of their modern society as being indifferent and lacking in civic mindedness only helped this story stand out further, just like when the Wenzhou guy tossed his bike at some purse snatchers. This girl had the wits to catch the pickpocket red handed on video with her iPad, spoke up, and even kept the thieving woman there instead of letting her run away, against the “conventional wisdom” that such thieves in Shanghai are usually Xinjiang people and they’re allowed to carry knives they’re not afraid to use.

      Another factor that helps this story get attention is the persistent phenomenon of pregnant thieves, as mentioned in the comments. People hate the idea that there are people so shameless as to use pregnancy as a get out of jail card. The rumors are that there are literally women who get visibly pregnant to thieve with impunity, abort, and repeat. There was a news story about one such woman doing this to steal mopeds awhile back.

      So you have a perfect storm. Think of the actually rather banal stories that get reported simply because it got some play on Twitter or Facebook, and you’ll understand why this story about someone helping a stranger on Weibo got attention.

      • Ray

        I thought posts on ChinaSmack are VERY popular posts from the mainstream Chinese forums. Comparing that little article you linked with 0 comments is hardly fair to say that any news like this can catch so much attention. Only in China *insert Meme*

        • anon

          You asked if someone helping a strange would get “any attention at all in another country?” I ran a quick search and gave you one of the results. It happens to be quite similar in its details, though not in a city as large as Shanghai with 20 million people.

          I also mentioned the Reddit charity cases, and prompted you to think of all the other Twitter and Facebook cases while explaining to you how this case is similar, how its all about the power of social media. You know what an internet meme is, so I’m assuming you have SOME basic awareness of internet phenomena and media outside of China, right?

          What don’t you understand?

      • Chad

        lol. Why do you even bother writing such a long reply to one of the hundreds of trolling comments on this site?

        • anon

          I try to contribute more information and explanation to the comments section when it comes to understanding any phenomenon. I do of course occasionally get taken in by some of the trolling and comments that are thrown out without much thought. In my opinion, chinaSMACK is fortunately less troll heavy than its copycat competitors, and there are some good sincere conversations that happen here.

    • Steve

      Obviously what the Kardashians are wearing is much more newsworthy then this.

  • mistyken

    Oh man one of the guy actually said knock that thief down the ground to make her loose her baby. That’s just too much. We are talking about human live vs a phone here. That’s just wrong.

    • anon

      It’s actually just a bit of black humor, not uncommon online. He’s expressing his suspicion that the woman is intentionally using pregnancy to flaunt the law. That’s why he says they can take her away after she has a miscarriage, because then she couldn’t exploit the loophole for pregnant women.

    • rollin wit 9′s

      FCK that! had it been me I would have broken her fckn arm, cuz that’s what the next idiot that tries to touch anything of mine is going to get. Had enough phones stolen in this sh!t hole from pickpockets. If you’re going to rob me, fkn rob me, dont be no b!tch about the process.

      • Ryo

        Well, how about you protect your shit better? I’ve been here 4+ years and never had anything stolen on me. I don’t keep my iPhone on the fucking table trying to show other people that I have an iPhone. I can feel incoming calls just fine when it’s in my jeans pocket. I keep my wallet in my front pocket. This works 100% of the time.

        Well, I think I did lose a few RMB in my car’s ash tray when I had it in for a wash but that’s a given almost.

        I once had all my spare change stolen in the states when I went though a car wash as well… lol

  • Snapp

    “Sorry, this video can only be streamed within mainland China”

    How long has this been happening?

    • anon

      I remember Youku doing this for quite some time, sometimes to hide certain copyrighted material from foreign eyes while keeping it available for domestic audiences who don’t care. Not sure why these videos are blocked. They’re just news clips.

      • themig

        actually its the region coding outside China. Diferent countries have different censorship levels. Saudi arabia bans 99% of chinese stuff. while US DOJ filters out anything which does not have an american copyright on it from google,youtube yahoo etc

  • jiayi

    Yeah! Take your tops off!

  • lonetrey

    A fun story to read about. Thank you Fauna!

  • Wayne

    Could you all consider doing a piece about Jordan suiting the daylights out of the Qiao Dan company for using his name to build their company? I wonder if the Chinese people are supporting MJ on this.

    • anon

      They are. Chinese people know the Qiaodan is just piggybacking on Jordan’s fame. If they didn’t before, they know now, and Chinese people hate other Chinese people trying to sell them Chinese stuff as foreign.

  • Alan

    to which Wang replied, “I filmed it with my iPad!”

    I don’t feel she deserves any praise at all.

    I’d be more impressed if she did not have an ipad, which is a piece of crap anyway, and actually did something to physically stop the thief. Disgusting and me me me…..

    • Kong

      Re-read the article. Wang held the thief there until the police arrived.

      • http://candosino.wordpress.com terroir

        Still, it’s noteworthy that this person committed good with a piece of not just any technology, but prized and valuable technology.

        This will just reinforce the notion that justice and morality are luxuries for the rich. To be downloaded from the iTunes store.

        • Alan

          This will just reinforce the notion that justice and morality are luxuries for the rich.

          Exactly. Maybe she should address the social inequalities that drive uyghurs to steal, instead of getting all moral and bignoting herself.

          • dilladonuts

            Go hug a tree

          • Sherry

            I wonder why she filmed it in the beginning. For evidence? Why didn’t she just call the woman out?

          • dilladonuts

            @Sherry

            Because in China, you need as much proof as possible. Don’t be such a hater, what’s wrong with what the girl did, she filmed someone stealing something, then held her until the cops came.

          • Kong

            Right, because the well-intentioned 阿姨 who tried to help Yue Yue was soaking in cash. Unless you were attempting an astute observation that people who don’t have to live day-to-day can aford to worry about others? Good one.

        • Alan

          @ donuts boy:

          Go hug a tree

          The issue is not one of the environment, so that comment is irrelevant and uncalled for.

          You go and hug your LV purse with your mastercards now.

          • dilladonuts

            weak, jealousy is a female trait.

          • Alan

            weak, jealousy is a female trait.

            Wrong, a human trait.

            But this issue is not one of jealousy.

            She could give her ipad up and feed a school full of kids. Bet she won’t and you won’t either!

    • anon

      Right, she confronted the thief, pushed her back towards the subway carriage where the thief slipped the phone back into the victim’s pocket, hollered at the victim to report it to the police, openly accused the thief in front of everyone, held her there, got hit several times, had her property knocked to the ground, and went with the police to report the incident.

      And she seems to have done this before. How is this me me me?

      • Sherry

        Yea. Looks like she did it all for fame.

        • anon

          Eh, I don’t think there’s enough to really make that allegation. On her Weibo, she announced she wouldn’t be accepting any more interviews with the media because it was affecting the people around her. I think she’s just been the victim of pickpocketing too many times before and became something of a small time crusader about it. There are better arguments for fame seeking against other people, like Sister Feng, Gan LuLu, or even AWW.

  • Brett Hunan

    天下无贼 is one of my favorite contemporary Chinese dramas. Stealing when pregnant cannot be good for karma, or virtue, or whatever Buddhists call it.

  • Cardaver

    Dude, that ‘World without thieves’ movie was boring, it sucked

    • Kong

      顶 The second half was just retarded.

  • Bryan

    any bravery in just way should be lauded.

  • Bunny99

    Can’t the law be changed so that a pregnant woman who committed a crime can be prosecuted x number of months after she has given birth? Once the evidence has been collected the law can wait.

    I understand that finding these women again 12 months later to prosecute them is difficult, but if they know they will be on a police wanted list and hunted forever until they get caught or die, that should be some deterrent. Better than nothing.

  • Rick in China

    @comments like “They’re intentionally using the legal loophole for pregnant women to commit crime.”

    Being on Bail doesn’t mean you’re released of conviction, it’s just in process of filing the case.. means you’re allowed some freedom but can’t leave the city while they investigate.

    I know, because I’m on fucking bail right now.

  • Glorious Hero

    Those people in the background want some popcorn. Honestly, why just stand there and watch? – let’s eat popcorn and watch!
    Good thing though this story has an happy end.

  • jeffli

    pickpocketing does not bring a big income or show promise of a career future.
    So a Pregnant lady pickpocketing is either desperate or controlled by someone.

    this young lady did good videoing the pickpocket but it highlights another problem.

  • Nillig

    I did this (stopped a pickpocket red-handed) in Nanjing in between the main train station and the bus station in 2007. I received no praise.

  • Sherry

    If it were me, I’d just have called the woman out, and as she put back the phone, I’d have just let her go after some warning, especially when she’s a pregnant woman. No need to wrestle her and make a big deal about this, and act out the “female knight” scene then upload it to the net for everyone to see.

    • notorious

      when i see a woman who resorts to stealing, i don’t feel anger, i feel compassion for her. but then I wonder how I would feel if her hands were in my purse.

    • anon

      Let’s ignore the fact that some people are using being pregnant to get cut slack for their misdeeds, like people using children to panhandle. The thief here put the phone back so there was no evidence and then turned around, lied straight faced, and started attacking her. The girl was mostly on the defensive, her only aggression was to expose the thief red handed and try to keep her there.

      We bitch and whine about Chinese people not having any civic-mindedness, compassion for their fellow people, or sense of justice, and here you have one who does, but you think she’s acting and making a big deal about it?

      Some of you are being blinded by the pregnancy. While there’s no proof that she’s intentionally exploiting the pregnancy loophole and thus we can’t accuse you of mistakenly extending the sympathy and leniency she’s hoping her pregnant state will get, it’s also irrelevant to the fact that she committed a crime.

      The girl uploaded it to her own microblog account to share an experience. That’s what people do when they use Twitter or post to their blog. That’s what so many people do when they come on this site and post about how much contempt they have for the Chinese because of this or that bad experience.

      It’s a good thing that there are people standing up to the “small” things, the “petty” crimes. It’s not much use tackling the large crimes of systematic corruption if you let slide petty thievery.

      • Fu ZhiGao

        bored are we mr. anon?

      • Sherry

        Whoa a wall of text

        You’re right, I didn’t read the caption where the pregnant woman denied stealing stuff even when caught red-handed. Can’t believe such people exist with no shame in denying something obvious. Still we shouldn’t be too quick to condemn her, we know nothing of her circumstance. My 2 cents.

    • Alan

      If it was a han chinese, and not an uighur thief, would it have been any different I wonder? Hmmmmmm!

      • Sherry

        The thief is Uighur?

      • mr. wiener

        Where in the article did it say that the pick pocket was a Uighur? All I say was one of the chinese netizins saying “Xingjuing people go home”.
        unless you know this for a fact you are jumpng to conclusions which is a poor form of exercise :)

        • Alan

          Does the article state otherwise? If not, it could well be an uighur.

  • Nari

    Wow, someone does a good thing trying to stop theft, and so many people criticize her…. if you look at her original Weibo post, her face isn’t even shown. the footage below that shows her face is from the subway camera, something that should be obvious to anyone who sees the thief knocking her ipad out of her grip. She took a step to stop crime, and like anon said, shared the experience on her Weibo blog. I doubt she ever thought that the victim would actually find her and news stations would be knocking at her door. Regardless, she took a brave step and confronted a criminal while everyone else did nothing but stare. And you criticize her…?

  • Dat Ankle

    Ah, it has finally come the day here on ChinaSMACK where the readers have become just as skeptical as the Chinese if a good deed is done.

Personals @ chinaSMACK - Meet people, make friends, find lovers? Don't be so serious!»