Hong Kong, Western Media Hypocrisy, and Chinese Reactions

Hong Kong SAR flag with PRC national flag.

Hong Kong SAR flag with PRC national flag.

Currently the #1 trending microblog post on Chinese microblog platform Sina Weibo, with over 60k upvotes, 110k forwards/reshares, and 25k comments, is by a British academic

From Sina Weibo:

@JohnRoss431: It’s inconvenient for me to comment on Hong Kong’s 2017 Chief Executive general election issue, because I’m not Chinese after all. However, Western media reports on the Hong Kong issue have been too hypocritical. In the United Kingdom’s 150 years of colonial rule over Hong Kong, the UK never permitted Hong Kongers to elect the Governor, and the United States did not protest against the UK for it either. Now when the system designed by China for Hong Kong is far more democratic than that allowed by the UK, the United States instead strongly protests against the China’s government. While I’m at it, which school provides the best excavator skills?

Comments from Sina Weibo:


I don’t know politics, but your Chinese brings a tear to my eye.


Please don’t not meddle in Lanxiang‘s internal school affairs!!!

[Note: This is referring to the “excavator” jokes that have recently become a popular internet meme on Chinese internet posts/comments.]


For daring to speak the truth, let me firmly tell you: Lanxiang!


To see a foreigner speaking on behalf of China’s government, and then see how some Chinese people’s despise their own country, I’ve had enough. I only want to say: How cam a large and grand country that has only just been reborn from destruction and ruin make every single person happy? Which government has truly been able to to give their people 100% democracy? Then what are leaders for? Everyone in their role, doing their job. I don’t care how Hong Kongers feel, I’m still proud of being Chinese.


After you go back to your country, people are definitely going to say you’ve been brainwashed by the Chinese, hehe, but I support your fair and objective comment. Those troublemakers in the Hong Kong SAR should be punished through lawful means. The SAR government departments should firmly pursue legal liability against the troublemakers in accordance with the law.


Even saying something relatively objective can get one accused of being wumao, while those who curse/criticize the government are all normal people? This logic is also stupid. [生病]


[哈哈] To see such a down-to-earth comment before going to sleep, I cannot help but give the microblog owner [original poster] an upvote!


Haha, this laowai is perceptive/insightful! Although in the minority, he has hit the nail on the head, seeing things more clearly than many Hong Kongers…


The original poster can go to Bei Da Qing Niao, Shandong Lanxiang, and New East Cuisine School [all vocational schools] to take advanced studies. Then, you’ll be able to use a computer to control an excavator to cook dishes. [doge]


I really don’t understand, why are there so many people who support the fenqing-ism of Hong Kong students? Their American father has fattened up ISIS, and their British mother can’t even deal with Scotland. A bunch of children who haven’t even grown all their public hair wanting to cause a disturbance? Laughable!


Certain protests are inherently farces. Making a fuss without reason will be fruitless, and sooner or later must end.


Wanting democracy is no cause for blame, but those saying the UK wanted to give Hong Kong democracy a long time ago were it not for mainland pressure need to shut up. Go look at when China and the UK began their talks and when the British colonial government of Hong Kong proposed giving Hong Kongers democracy. Are you people really that naive? If they sincerely and genuinely wanted to give democracy, why didn’t they give it earlier, or has British democracy not been around long enough? I respect every person who fights for democracy, but despise those who deliberately whitewash British imperialism.


Hong Kong, you spineless cunt, back when your parents were being insulted/humiliated by Western nations, you were taken away to be slaves, and instead of doing your best to resist, you actually thought it was great. Your parents worked hard to finally bring you back and you instead spend every day looking down on your parents, constantly cursing them, calling them cunts, and when they don’t agree to your unreasonable demands, you threaten that you want to go back to being a slave dog. This kind of trollish argument definitely won’t work, and I hope the central government will adopt unyielding measures.


If there are any Hong Kong friends [people] here, please pass this on. If there is anyone in the Mongkok Nathan Road area, I don’t oppose your peaceful protest, but can you guys please keep it down and not use loudspeakers? Brother [referring to self] has an early shift tomorrow. Otherwise, I’m going to piss out the window. [怒] So annoying.


Original poster, you know too much!!!

Written by Fauna

Fauna is a mysterious young Shanghainese girl who lives in the only place a Shanghainese person would ever want to live: Shanghai. In mid-2008, she started chinaSMACK to combine her hobby of browsing Chinese internet forums with her goal of improving her English. Through her tireless translation of popular Chinese internet news and phenomenon, her English has apparently gotten dramatically better. At least, reading and writing-wise. Unfortunately, she's still not confident enough to have written this bio, about herself, by herself.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.