Wenzhou Train Crash Compensation & Rail Official Takes Plane

Chinese netizen photoshop of the China Railway logo, changing it into a coffin.

From NetEase:

First [Wenzhou] train rear-end collision accident victim compensation amount is 500,000 yuan

According to the Wenzhou municipal Party committee, and the latest information from the city government, there has been progress in the discussions concerning compensation for victims of the Yong-Wen Line Exceptionally Serious Railway Accident. Through the initial agreement between the local post-disaster handling “5+1″ [5 government representatives + 1 Railway Ministry representative] service group and the family members of victim Lin Yan, a compensation amount of 500,000 yuan was reached. Lin Yan is from Fuzhou of Fujian province. This the first compensation discussion to have achieved an initial agreement in this accident.

Separately, according to identification documents, clothing and other distinguishing characteristics, the remains of the 39 victims have all been claimed, but at still waiting for DNA identification for confirmation.

From NetEase:

Compensation scheme introduced, first to sign agreement may be rewarded

As it is understood, according to the Railway Ministry’s relevant regulations, the compensation standard is set at 172,000 yuan as the base amount plus 200,000 yuan insurance settlement for a total of 372,000 yuan. This base amount is set and will not change. When transportation expenses, burial expenses, and old age financial support is added for the families of the victims, the total amount rises to no more than 450,000 yuan, and those who accept negotiations and sign agreements within a short time after the incident may, as appropriate, be given [an additional] several tens of thousands of yuan as a reward. The above expenses apart from the reward will be paid by the government of the victim’s household registration, with the rest paid by the Railway Ministry, to be paid in cash or charge card, principally with charge cards, with the entire negotiation to respect the deceased as the number one principle.

Comments from NetEase:

0663972090 [网易广东省东莞市网友]:

MLGB! Reward? Disgusting!

网易火星手机网友:

The first to sign even gets a reward??!! Beasts!

wenliyuanxinping [网易福建省厦门市网友]:

Life is impossible now. Take the subway, and the escalator collapses. Ride the train, and you get rear-ended. Take the bus, get barbequed. Drink some water, and there are worms in the Nongfu spring. Eat some meat, and Bajie is more expensive than Xuanzang [pork is more expensive than meat that can make you immortal]. Watch basketball, and Yao Ming retires. Watch football, and even Laos gets two goals against us. Set up a stall on the street, and black society [organized crime, hoodlums] have become the chengguan. Make a donation, and the money is used to buy Maseratis.

网易安徽省合肥市网友:

Fucking just like fucking forced eviction & demolitions!

网易火星手机网友:

How much for the foreigners?

8642480985 [网易上海市网友]:

The people just died, are still on the road to heaven, and before giving them an explanation, you pressure the families to discuss compensation, how can you bring yourselves to do such a thing!!!

抓紧移民 [网易上海市网友]:

This is what the GCD‘s officials are like!!! Fucking fuck!!!

网易上海市网友:

Compensation and reward: Even in death people are not equal. What the hell is this!?

皮特竹 [网易上海市徐汇区网友]:

Life is cheap like this, dying of dubious causes and then rushing people to first take the money. Is it because they’re planning to close the case once the money is taken?! This is blatant disregard of humanity!

jsmj2008 [网易福建省泉州市网友]:

After compensating, they’ll then increase prices again, and earn back that money. The pitiful ones are the dead, having been test subjects for this group of inhuman bastards.

网易浙江省宁波市网友:

Using the word “reward” with disaster compensation is a bit offensive, as if dealing with residents facing demolition [offering money to residents to sell their property to allow for demolition and redevelopment].

8806830256 [网易上海市网友]:

Very characteristic. [Joking about "Chinese characteristics".]

China Railway Logo photoshops by Chinese netizens:

The image at the top of this article and the image below are some Photoshops circulating on Sina Weibo making fun of China Railways. The top image was posted by @品牌研究中心, while this one below was posted by @苏囧.

China Railways logo photoshop by Chinese netizens, bloody middle finger.

Railway Ministry spokesperson Wang Yongping takes plane instead of train:

We mentioned Wang Yongping in an earlier report, as the government official who became infamous for his responses to reporters at a press conference following the Wenzhou high-speed train accident.

@go佳佳佳: We’re on the same flight as Wang Yongping. He’s sitting in first class. Already changed into slippers, and is reading the newspaper. Dears, should I charge over and interview him????

Infamous Railway Ministry spokesperson Wang Yongping in first class flight back to Beijing.

@想做薛定谔的猫: Confirmed, Railway Ministry spokesperson Wang Yongping is taking a flight back to Beijing; first class. Why not take today’s hurriedly restored train service to Shanghai and then take the high-speed train he says is “very technologically advanced and very confident in” back to Beijing? As a news spokesperson and for the Railway Ministry’s public image, shouldn’t you practice what you preach?

Chinese netizen Sina Weibo user @go佳佳佳 says Railway Ministry spokesperson Wang Yongping is on the same flight.

In fact, one of Wang Yongping’s responses (“whether you believe or not, I believe”) suggesting that it doesn’t matter if the press or people believe his explanations because all that matters is that he believes it has become a new Chinese internet meme.

  • angryman

    Ha! Like the officials ever take the train.

    • Going going gone

      Oddly the new G models, contain a section in the front carriage reserved for just that reason, huge plush comfy seats and a clear screen through in to the drivers compartment.

      Unless this is actually first class, then I doubt it will ever be used for its intended purpose.

      • Ash

        Its the ‘special seat department’ according to the ticket for one that I took recently. The cost was 70+ rmb instead of the usual 40rmb.

        Pretty good ride actually, the ‘air hostess’ offers you a bottle of juice and tries to keep the riff raff out, but of course they all try to push in to get a drivers view and shout out classic back seat comments such as ‘He’s going the wrong way!’ etc etc.

    • vic2u

      In the US they have govt planes and choppers.

  • fubai haodehen

    Well obviously he never has or ever will take the train. “Qiong ren tai duo le!”

  • kevinnolongerinpudong

    Such an important official needs to go first class, cut off even from coach- otherwise he would have gotten all Lei Feng on everyone’s asses, shining their shoes and sewing up the holes on their socks and shit like that. He just can’t help it! His eagerness to “serve the people” might have distracted him from his much more important duties as the spokesperson of the Railway Ministry, like lying through his teeth and pretending to care.
    By the way, why does the Railway Ministry need a spokesperson? Is this a new position created in just the past few days?

    • anon

      Why wouldn’t the Railway Ministry need a spokesperson? It’s just like a PR position, someone to deal with reporters and the public, often in situations like these. Can’t say he’s done a good job of it though…

    • http://www.foarp.blogspot.com FOARP

      Remindws me of an excercise I did back in my English teaching days – I asked a university class to describe their stereotype of a people who did certain jobs. One was “politician”.

      Whilst most people had the sanity to say that politicians were usually well-off and drove around in Audis, one student in all seriousness described them as riding around on bicycles and doing everything for the people. She really blieved it – a testimony to brainwashing.

    • http://www.foarp.blogspot.com FOARP

      Reminds me of an excercise I did back in my English teaching days – I asked a university class to describe their stereotype of a people who did certain jobs. One was “politician”.

      Whilst most people had the sanity to say that politicians were usually well-off and drove around in Audis, one student in all seriousness described them as riding around on bicycles and doing everything for the people. She really believed it – a testimony to brainwashing.

  • JAYJAY

    So the figure from BBC is true. It is peanuts!!

    The money paid out to families should act not only as compensations but also as a deterrent to stop companies/governments departments being irresponsible in the future. A higher amount will actually mean something, and companies/departments will look at the actual costs of compensations and learn to do things right next time. It might be considered as punitive in nature, but it is also a tell-tell sign for the companies/departments to learn from this and avoid such accidents like this in the future.

    More to the point, because this kind of tragic accidents usually is a corporate responsibility or corporate manslaughters if you like, one can not pin the blame on just one or a few individuals/officials. This might be due to a series of decisions made over a period of time. So a higher compensation is more appropriate than putting some in prison/on death row. But I think the current level of compensation recommended by the government is a slap on the wrist for those who are responsible.

    • Xiongmao

      The 500.000 number is technically incorrect, since it’s not China Railways/China’s government paying out the 200.000, but an insurance company. Of course it sounds better to say 500K than 174…

    • anon

      I think there are legal maximums involved, something I remember an old chinaSMACK post mentioning where Chinese netizens commented. I forgot which post it was though.

  • Nyancat

    cool logo, creativity at it’s finest!

  • Alikese

    OMG, the back of somebody’s head on an airplane? Well that’s some pretty damning proof. He even has black hair, it must be Wang Yongping.

    • anon

      It’s possible that the photo doesn’t actually show Wang Yongping and was only posted by the Weibo user to show that she’s on the plane. People do that all the time on Twitter as well.

      • Just John

        Nah, it’s proof.
        It’s the picture of a guy, on a plane, with black hair.

        It must be him, we cannot argue the facts he is a guy, with black hair.

        • anon

          I don’t know. Those don’t look like first class seats, and that would pretty clearly contradict the tweet so the more rational explanation would be that the picture is just meant to supplement testimony as the tweeter being on the plane than the guy in the seat in front being Wang Yongping. If Wang Yongping is in first class, the tweeter may have walked past while boarding, saw that he was in slippers (first class boards first) and reading a newspaper, then sat down and tweeted what he or she saw, taking a photo to show that he or she is on a plane, and pointing it towards the front of the plane.

          I’m not saying someone’s hearsay and that photo alone is sufficient proof that Wang Yongping actually was on that plane, but I’m just trying to explain that the photo may not necessarily have been intended by the tweeter to show Wang Yongping’s actual person.

          • Just John

            O, no worries. I understand what you are saying.

            I was just trying to brush up on my internet sarcasm, similar to Alikese’s comment.

            It is so hard at times to do internet sarcasm since people only have the words to read, and not the tone, posture, facial expression, etc.

            Always need to hone the old skills for those truly sarcastic worthy posts (Like eco girl’s response in the India pictures).

    • http://candosino.wordpress.com terroir

      Whether you believe or not, I certainly do.

      Pass it on.

  • Xiongmao

    “..the Yong-Wen Line Exceptionally Serious Railway Accident”

    Did you get the txt too Fauna?

    • mankouzanghua

      all she did was translate what someone else wrote in chinese — 甬温线特别重大铁路交通事故

      if anyone got the text it was the poster on netease

  • Spanky

    Two foreigners were killed too. Wonder what their compensation will be.

    • mr. weiner

      ..it depends on if they were Japanese or not.

      • anon

        I think they were American but apart from the opinions of some stupid nationalists, being Japanese hasn’t actually affected compensation amounts in these sort of cases in China.

      • Just John

        I was wondering, are you an all beef weiner, or a lips and assholes from different animals weiner?

        Just more of a curiosity then anything pertinent to anything.

  • fix it!

    fix the RSS feed, this story didn’t get fed through feedburner!!!

  • Keekee

    It really makes me sad, depressed, and almost ashamed to be of Chinese descent reading how the government is handling this tragic incident…

    • staylost

      The government doesn’t speak for, or represent “Chinese”. Be proud of who you are. Nearly everyone around the world realizes the huge disconnect between the current party in power and the spirit & heritage of the Chinese.

      • Irvin

        Agreed, just read some of the comments translated for the real sentiments of the average chinese.

        The CPC definitely doesn’t represent majority of the citizens of china.

  • Justin

    Not to defend any sort of cover-up, but there’s a kind of Catch 22 involved in China’s media control.

    If there were no management of the media and everyone in China knew everything that the government did, there would be riots in the streets. But the price of this “stability” is that corruption and mismanagement go habitually unchecked to the extent that such disasters are bound to happen. This also leads to instability, but of a much more manageable variety.

    The kind of instability that results from sporadic disasters is much easier to control via the traditional mechanisms of “guidance of public opinion” and armed force. If the government unleashed the press to find the real dirt, it would open up a Pandora’s box containing a shit storm of epic proportions.

    Now, while it’s true that the average CPC member is probably more interested in maintaining his or her own power than doing what is best in the interests of the country, there is no doubt as to which form of instability is the lesser of two evils, from their perspective at least.

    • staylost

      This, of course, being less of a problem when people feel like they have a say in the government.

      I know you aren’t trying to defend it, but I also want to bring out the comparison to the simple “mother’s advice;” that whenever you lie, you have to lie again and again until the lie becomes so big you can’t control it anymore. The destruction and loss of trust unleashed from this eventual burst bubble of lies, is far greater than any loss that would have occurred were the lie forgone entirely.

      Covering up the situation and controlling the media ensures the people simmer in their disgust at their own government. It is really sad.

  • staylost

    Hey, Guess What! Premier Wen just found time to visit the crash site.

    I think they are pulling a George W./Hurricane Katrina stunt here!

    A good example, since he handled the PR on that one so well.

    • Wade

      Premier Wen doesn’t care about Chinese people.

      • http://www.foarp.blogspot.com FOARP

        Awesome. (*looks at camera as if to say “he’s finally flipped, folks”*)

      • vic2u

        “Premier Wen doesn’t care about Chinese people.”

        That’s OK.

        Obama doesn’t care about Chinese people either, he will screw China to the walls but Chinese people love him longtime.

  • typingfromwork

    While it is probably just common sense that the official took the flight (as it is faster) in these media sensitive times it would have been prudent for him to go by train, and therefore restore some of the confidence the public has over the network.

    It’s a bit like how that oil executive went yachting during the BP Gulf oil spill. Sure, you’ve probably had the holiday booked months in advance and are taking your justly earned time off, but it was a bit of an insensitive gesture and reduced the publics confidence in them even more.

    • anon

      Right, or how the CEOs of the American auto companies took a plane when asking for a bailout and then next time drove after all the public outrage.

  • Irvin

    And so it begins, everything has a price even people’s principles. I reckon most will accept the offer and keep quiet and in a few years the cycle will begins anew on another “accident”.

    But just imagine…….what if none accept the money but instead they all demand an explanation? That’s something we’ll never know in china for the citizen is as much to blame for the corruption as the government.

  • Meh

    The top image made me chuckle sadly at how appropriate it is. A casket. Well done.

  • 平凡人

    Why in such a hurry to settle compensation? Trying to reduce the “noise”they are getting? What happened to the actual root cause of the accident?
    I have recevied information that railway spokesman Wang Yong Ping has got many relatives working in the railway company. A company with so many relatives inside, no wonder it is corrupted.

  • vic2u

    Mon so low class, in the US they have their own planes.

    And in the US the officials take a chopper to get there so they don’t have to touch the contaminated ground.

    Chinese govt workers are so far behind the US and western countries in PR stuffs.

  • Foreign Devil

    I just want to know if they retrieved ALL the bodies for proper ID and burial before they started rolling and burying those train cars.

    • Just John

      Are you kidding?

      That would directly conflict with the hide it and then report a very low number so the public doesn’t loose faith.

      If they did it your way, someone might actually find out the real number of dead.

Personals @ chinaSMACK - Meet people, make friends, find lovers? Don't be so serious!»